[Company Logo Image]Up President's Page SAA Contacts Events Diary Constitution Membership Veteran's Affairs Our History Newsletters Up Periscope Search Feedback Form Thales Australia                      

November 07
 

      

 

Home
Up

 

 

 

 

 

IN DEPTH
Proudly sponsored by

RAYTHEON AUSTRALIA

Email: nsecsaa@wix.com.au

Print Post Approved PP241218/00012


98 Yelverton Street,
SYDENHAM NSW 2044

Tel: (02) 9519 8745
Fax: (02) 9557 1480

 

VOLUME 27 NUMBER 6  

NOVEMBER 2007

 

SAA Website - Up Periscope

http://submarinesaustralia.com/

 

DISCLAIMER: The opinions or exertions expressed in "In Depth" are those of the authors’ and not necessarily those of the Editor, the National and State Committees of the SAA, Raytheon Australia or the Royal Australian Navy.


DISCLAIMER: The opinions or exertions expressed in "In Depth" are those of the authors’ and not necessarily those of the Editor, the National and State Committees of the SAA, Raytheon Australia or the Royal Australian Navy.


Proud to sponsor "In Depth" and support the Submarines Association Australia

TAKE NOTE: The Secretary’s internet server has been taken over and as of now the new address is nsecsaa@wix.com.au so drop the localnet and replace with wix.

PRESIDENT’S REPORT - FROM THE AMS
I will start this communication by issuing an apology to the members of the SAA.

One of the things I pride myself on is my ability to communicate, (communicate-transitive verb to transmit or reveal a feeling or thought by speech, writing, or gesture so that it is clearly understood) since the AGM I have been somewhat silent in that regard.

To defend the defenceless, there are times in my life when (unfortunately) I let business interfere with my extracurricular activities.

At the AGM the SAA National Executive made a commitment to have an audited set of accounts available to the membership within 90 days. This has not been achieved (not through a lack of commitment on anyone’s part). A report on the current status of the SAA was sent to the National Committee showing assents the SAA is in a healthy position financially.

We were unable to reconcile the current accounts to the previous (2006) accounts as the previous Treasurer(s) were un-contactable (for somewhat different reasons). Subsequently Peter Vidler has been found and has volunteered to travel to WA and provide JR with sufficient information so as to enable the accounts to be audited. This is where timing just wasn’t with us, when JR was around we couldn’t locate Peter, now we have founds Pete, JR has done a “Dags” and gone walkabout.

The audited reports will be provided as soon as it is practical to do so, however, as previously stated; the SAA is in a healthy state financially.

Since my last visit to the AMS, we have had the re-dedication of Waller, held at Fleet Base West. Fortunately through the good graces of my employers I was able to arrange to visit several of my clients in Perth which just happened to coincide with the re-dedication ceremony.

We have also had the (what would have been the 40th birthday) celebrations at “Plats”. I would like to personally thank all those who attended, (it read like a “who’s who” of not only the submarine community, but local, state and federal government representatives). Special thanks to the SAA NSW Branch for the organisation and to TS Sydney and TS Condamine for the work they did in making the site look like something more than a ghost town.

Back on the “communications” thread for a moment, I think the move to split the “Log” from the SAA “official” website was not in the best interest of the Association and has resulted in one site which is “hit” frequently and one that is left in the shadows. I would like to see "The Log” back on the SAA website and would appreciate your feedback on this.

Still on “communications”, if at any time you feel the need please feel free to contact me My contact details are on the SAA website.

Finally, a BZ to the SAA SA Branch, for providing those who attended SUBCON 2007 the AGM and festivities in Adelaide, a wonderful experience.

I believe this will be the last “In Depth” until 2008, therefore I would take this opportunity to wish you and yours all the very best for Christmas and pray that 2008 will see you all in good health and spirit.

Dave (Sandy) Sandquest
National President, Submarines Association Australia
 

NATIONAL PENSIONS & WELFARE COORDINATOR BULLETIN
MAX HARDY 02 92648188 mhardy@rslnsw.com.au

At the time of going to print the reports that Max had sent have not been received. However if you have any problems, for assistance with ‘Health & Welfare’ matters contact an authorised Pension/ Welfare Officer

Western Australia
Tony Critchley 08 9795 5346 critch@hotmail.com.au
Roger Hardwicke 08 9305 1569 denrog@bigpond.net.au
Greg Shimmen 041 892 4559 greg_shimmen@yahoo.com.au
John Keating 08 9527 7963 keatingclan@optusnet.com.au
John Rana
ranaoxley@exemail.com.au

ACT & Northern Regions
Tom Johnston JP 02 62382425
lozza@netspeed.com.au

Victoria
Fes Parker 040948379 daparker@tpg.com.au
Hastings
Greg Pennicuik 03 59774128 grandi@aapt.net.au
Cranbourne
John Sullivan 040197550
john.l.sullivan@exxonmobil.com

South Australia
Alan Johnstone 08 87382213
vicptmacpub@net.au
Ken Grierson 08 8364 0346 kgrierso@bigpond.net.au

Queensland
Brian Earle 07 4956728 brianearle@bigpond.com
Ian Sinclair 07 55477621 gtrxian@bigpond.com
Ian Prodger 07 46662448 ianprodger@bigpond.com

New South Wales
Sydney
Jim Seager JP 02 9824 0833 or
(the AVADSC Office, ‘Centennial Plaza’, 1st Floor, 280 Elizabeth St. Surry Hills, the DVA building)
John Hodges JP 02 9908 5330
jhodges@rslnswcom.au
Max Hardy 02 4774 0542 maxhardy@ipentire.com
(John and Max can also be contacted at NSW RSL Headquarters 02 9624 8188)
Dave Williams 041 981 3741dwil795@bigpond.net.au
Central Coast
Brett Ollington 02 4388 1430 uboat2@bigpond.com.au
Nowra
Bob O’Grady 02 4423 0846 bomorslsub@shoal.net.au
Alex Paton 02 4443 4281 patonplace@southernphone.com.au
Holbrook
Jim Redwood 02 6036 2017 annejim@bigpond.com
Cootamundra
Ian Taber 02 69427241 rebatai@optusnet.com.au
Finley
Peter Vidler 03 58834251 reldiv@optusnet.com.au
North Coast
Alison McKean 02 65668378 go_slow@optusnet.com.au
Arthur McKean 02 65668378 go_slow@optusnet.com.au
Kevin Hayton 02 66534146 kghayton@optusnet.com.au

CORRESPONDENCE
Dear Pete,
Interested to read Nick Hall's article on the T boats in the September Newsletter but disappointed that Thule didn't get a mention. Under the Command of, I think Alastair Mars, the boat had a distinguished record in the Med. and this was the subject of his book "HMS Thule Intercepts". The boat was never streamlined or converted and I was the Third Hand of what was probably Thule's last commission in 1961, clockwork mousing for work up ships at Portland. Phil Toms, whose recent death was noted in a previous newsletter, was the Engineer.
Regards,
Mark Wareham


Dear Peter
Some 9 months ago Pat Cullum rang me and asked me what I thought about some sort of commemoration plaque for the 4th Squadron at HMAS Penguin, I replied that it was a brilliant idea. Pat then approached the CO of Penguin Commander Roger Dobson RAN who liked the idea and promised his assistance to carry it out.

Pat then hunted down the piece of sandstone, which had been waiting millions of years for this opportunity to be a star, and, after obtaining this, started working on a plaque design.

The plaque itself was another matter as we had to get the dates of the boats serviced spot on , and after a lot of research it came out in its present form and was duly inscribed by a local company at Narrabri

Pat then worked on the stone to prepare an area to take the plaque, and at the top, a shelf area to fold a model “T” boat, which had been copied from a model of one owned by Dick Mason.

The stone was brought to Penguin on Saturday morning 29 September where it was off loaded and had an insert carved out by Pat, Tony Maddock and yours truly, to take the supporting stone.

On completion it was lowered by Hi Ab onto the site which had been prepared by Tony Maddock on the Friday. The plaque was then fitted to the stone and the “T” boat fitted into the shelf. We then moved to the barbeque area to prepare the seating in the marquees and stow the drinks in the portable cool room.

On the Saturday night, around 30 of us gathered with wives at the Oaks Hotel, where over some pizzas and beers lots of stories were swapped, then back to Buena Vista where a number of us were staying.

On Sunday we arrived early to set up a reception area and make sure all else was in order and at around 9.30 am the first arrival trickled in. Some had not been back to Penguin since their service days and were anxious to look around their old base.

On arrival and registration all were given a name tag sticker and an engraved pen memento, which had been provided by my good friend Roger Shayer of Scribal, an ex Southsea boy now living in Terrigal.

Many were held up due to the traffic through Mosman, including Bill Owen who was to do the unveiling of the plaque, but arrived in time for the ceremony.

Bill made a speech covering the 4th’s history then called on Pat to say a few words, which he did. Pat then said he wished to present a plaque replica and a cap to FOSM, Rear Admiral David Cook RN, the Admiral stood up and Pat then said “Rear Admiral Cook one pace forward, March!” which the admiral in good part did. Pat presented the replica and cap and then stated, “I’ve always wanted to do that.” He then thanked the Admiral, his aide Captain Suchet RN and Brigadier Robins for attending.

The Padre, Reverend Simon Hubbard CSC RAN (Rtd) then blessed the occasion.

A WW2 submariner Dr Colin Douglas-Smith, who had travelled from WA, then gave a speech as to how he came to be in submarines and his wartime experiences. On completion Bill Owen unveiled the plaque and invited all to partake of a tot and lunch in the barbeque area near the jetty, where beer wine and soft drinks were provided. Joe Everton did the honours as rum bosun, then lunch was on.

Commander Dobson was unable to attend but his Executive Officer Lieutenant Commander Shaw RAN was on hand and she made sure that all went well, for which we thank her and to the Duty Chief for her assistance. Some of the participants had travelled a long way, Dave Summers from the UK, others from New Zealand, New Caledonia, Alan Jamieson and others from WA, Victoria and Queensland, all up 112 attendees on the day.

Bill Starkey provided a door prize of two tickets to the Maritime Museum, drawn by the Admiral and won by Tansy Lee.

The Admiral remarked that he was amazed at the camaraderie and how we had all kept together after all these years.

One back mark on the day was when we discovered some light fingered person had purloined an engraved hip flask of Nelson’s Blood rum which Pat intended to present. I was ashamed that a submariner would steal from another, practically unknown in the service. If, on reading this he can return it anonymously to Pat or myself, no questions asked.

It was a memorable day otherwise and I have several phone calls to assure me of this, the weather being just perfect for the occasion.

Several people sadly could not attend due to circumstances beyond their control, family illness, etc, including Mike Pearson who is at the present time very ill. Our best wishes for a speedy recovery.

Let’s hope we can all get together again in the not too distant future. Thank you one and all for attending and making it such a memorable occasion.
Tom McCammont,
Terrigal NSW 2260


Dear Peter,
An item for the Newsletter “Bill Hudson" who worked for Boeing as the Project Director for the combat System during the Collins build has died from the Cancer and will be interred on Tuesday the 23rd. October". I believe many of your readers who knew and respected "Bill" would like to know this sad news.
Regards Tim Everard


Hi David,
The chemo people have given me 12months to stay upright. During the last few months I've met some great people suffering from this disease, the ones you feel most sorry for are the children and I feel I must do something for them. Therefore I would like to undertake a WALK FOR KIDS WITH CANCER from Brisbane to Canberra to arrive in time for SUBCON 08 with the donations going to Royal Children's Hospital, Brisbane and Westmead Children's Hospital in Sydney. I would like to involve the SAA and with the contacts our Members have in the Association I feel sure we could put this together quite easily.

It would take approximately six weeks and I believe it would enhance our Association's position in the Community. All we need is ten volunteers per week for six weeks.

I hope the SAA can get behind this and if I'm not too late get it into the next INDEPTH. At our last meeting in Maryborough the Members with a show of hands showed their enthusiasm for the project.
Regards, Bob Wilson,
Beenleigh Qld.

ACT & SR BRANCH
Secretary Geoff BURNS JP 02 48494330 0427 435 314 gcburns@clearmail.com.au

Unfortunately, there was no report from the ACT Branch prior to going to print. On behalf of the ACT President and Executive we wish you a Very Merry Christmas. ED.

NEW SOUTH WALES BRANCH
Secretary Ken WILLIAMS H 02-80042304 M 0400500604 email kenbwilliams@hotmail.com

At the time of going to press there was no report from the Branch however, I am sure Ken will keep you in the loop regarding information. On behalf of the NSW President and executive we wish you a Very Merry Christmas

NORTH QUEENSLAND BRANCH
Secretary Garth SCHMIDT email ssc83850@bigpond.net.au

G'day to all members. Well the time for our last meeting for the year fast approaches.

This meeting is scheduled for the weekend of 9,10 & 11 November and will be held in Ingham. It would be really great to catch up with as many members as possible to bring the year to a close and have an early kick-off to the festive season.

The meeting will be held in the Ingham R.S.L. Club with pre-meeting refreshments from midday to 1400. The meeting will be called at 1400 and we will be having dinner at the club at 1800.

For those that wish, there will be a meet and greet at the club at 1800 on the Friday evening, and members will join the RSL contingent for the Remembrance Day ceremony on the Sunday morning. I know that several members will be staying down at beautiful Forrest Beach and Snow Schleicher has booked several rooms at the local hotel /caravan park. Anyone that wants accommodation booked; please let me know, so that we can make the arrangements for you.

I will also need to know numbers attending the dinner on Saturday evening, so the RSL can provide the meals for us.

As usual, we will be running raffles & auctions for various SAA memorabilia.

Safe travelling to all and please come along to support your Nth Qld Branch....... these meetings are always great fun.

QUEENSLAND BRANCH
Secretary Rob H. WOOLRYCH MBE H 07-54421991 email robjanw@launch.net.au

Next Meeting:  When. Sunday 13 January 2008. Venue. Coorparoo R.S.L. 45 Holdsworth St, COORPAROO Time 1100
If there are any visitors to the area we would love to have you join us.

Remembrance Day: 1100 Sunday, 11 November 2007 at Coorparoo RSL – All welcome

It has been a good year for SAA Qld Inc with new members coming in and most importantly we have had some very good social occasions. The Social activities will continue for the next year and we hope get better. The Meeting recently held in Maryborough was a great success almost entirely due to the efforts of Ailsa and John Head - our sincere thanks to both of you. Ailsa's Heritage Walk was the only talk in our car on the way home.

There were nearly 30 of us at the meeting but the two important things were we had new faces and our wives were able to join in the weekend fun.

From the men's point of view the highlight of the weekend was the whale watching where our ladies were able to join in the fun and experience of "Sea Time" and we did see whales and their babies.

As a result of this weekend away meeting, we will have another away trip to a meeting
When, 11/12 October 2008. Where Stanthorpe
a. Saturday Wine Tour of the Vineyards
b. Meeting Stanthorpe RSL 1100 Sunday 12 Oct 2008
Any of you who wish to join us are very welcome to do so

SEASONS GREETINGS
From the President, Committee and Members of SAA Qld Inc to all ex-submariners wherever you are, have a Happy and Safe Christmas and stay well in 2008 and all the time Drive Carefully.

ONCE AGAIN THE IMPORTANT THING
Next Meeting is at the Coorparoo RSL on Sunday 13 January 2008 and all are most welcome

SOUTH AUSTRALIAN BRANCH
Secretary David BRYANT H 08-82630461 M 0412574790 email djbryant@senet.com.au

 At the time of going to press there was no news from the South Australian Branch; however I am sure that David will keep you informed. On behalf of the President and Executives we wish you a Very Merry Christmas.

TASMANIAN BRANCH
Secretary David BYRNE H. 03/6233588 Email: dbyrne@keypoint.com.au

This year’s Tasmanian Branch AGM was held in mid-September and a good number rocked up for a short but interesting meeting. It was agreed that Tassie’s laid back approach to meetings and other gatherings was spot on and that the outgoing Committee appeared to be getting the mix right. This was confirmed by having the same members re-elected to the same positions for another year! They are: President Kim Pitt, Secretary/Treasurer David Byrne, Member (North) Grant Beswick and Member (South) Mike Crellin.

The post-AGM lunch was also well attended and gave members from across the state the opportunity to catch up over a meal and a couple of beers. Ian Doig was true to his word when we met by accident at Hobart Airport in June and has officially joined the island state branch – welcome Dougal!

Occasionally we get wind of a former submariner who has moved to or retired to Tasmania. Unfortunately, we rarely get any more detail than that. If you know of someone who has moved here to God’s country and who you suspect is not a member of either the national or Tasmanian state organisations please either give them the Secretary’s contact details above or pass their details to David Byrne.

The President, Committee and Members of the Tasmanian Branch would like to take this opportunity to wish all of our submarine comrades and their families across the country and abroad all the very best wishes for Christmas and for a safe, prosperous and Happy New Year in 2008.

VICTORIAN BRANCH
Secretary Keith ‘Boot’ HATFIELD M 0408 051 085 email hatfield.1@optusnet.com.au

A friendly reminder to all. November's meeting will be held at the ESU, commencing 12 noon. Committee will meet at 11am. This is a promulgated Business Meeting and any items for Business should be in the hands of the Secretary 14 days prior to the meeting. 12 noon ESU, corner of Walsh Street and Toorak Road, November 18. It is hoped that Mike Rikard-Bell will be able to give an update on AE2 after the conclusion of Business at the meeting. Should prove to be very interesting. Hope to see you there.

16th December 1030 Christmas Dinner at the ESU, corner of Walsh Street and Toorak Road. Commence 12 noon. Contact Keith Hatfield for details.
On behalf of the President and Executive a Very Merry Christmas to one and all.

WESTERN AUSTRALIA BRANCH
Acting Secretary Lloyd (Joe) Blake H 08 94444912 M 0439943230 email lloydblake@iinet.net.au

The departure for greener pastures in Queensland sees us without a Secretary or Treasurer and in addition to my role as Branch Vice President I am acting Secretary and Norm is Acting Treasurer until the positions are filled.

As a result of the lack of Committee things have been pretty slow, but members can be assured that we are currently looking at the social calendar and will be promulgating future meetings and events shortly. Planning for the major event of the year, Remembrance Day alongside Ovens, held with the support of the WA Maritime Museum, is well advanced and it is hoped that all WA submarine community members will attend this important event.

The Branch has a few Members that are not travelling too well at the moment and it is a reminder to all to take time to contact old mates every now and then, that little bit of personal contact does more good than you realise.
Events Calendar: Remembrance Day Service Fremantle 1030-1100, Sunday 11 November.

The WA Branch will host the Remembrance service at the memorial plaque alongside Submarine Ovens at the WA Maritime Museum, Victoria Quay, Fremantle. The Service will start at 1030.

On completion of the service (30 minutes) members are invited to board Submarine Ovens with family and friends.
Fremantle’s Submarine Fleet: Between 1942 and 1945 a total of 164 submarines of the American, British and Dutch Navies were based and operated from Australian ports with Fremantle playing the largest role. Patrols by Fremantle based submarines accounted for the total tonnage sunk second only to that from submarines based at Pearl Harbour. Attending the service brings the lessons of history and demonstrates our support of submarines as an important National security asset.
 

  I thought that, in retirement, I would have much more time on my hands to play with the website, but to my surprise I have less, having two websites to maintain (submarinesaustralia.com and upperiscope.com.au) instead of one has made it more difficult to keep them in sync. I intend approaching the National Executive for permission to merge the sites again to resolve some problems that I am experiencing. I think one site makes it easier for visitors to use.

One of the problems I am having is that the two sites are under their own URLs (address) and this has resulted in broken links and pages that do not work. If you find any problems, please let me know so that I can fix them, if I don’t know I cannot fix them.

Remember, constructive criticism, suggestions for improvements and even complaints are always welcome. Remember, it is YOUR site and it is only as good as you make it

Thanks for your support
Norm Williams Web Manager

COMMANDER NORMAN SHAW RAN Rtd
Norman Shaw joined the RAN as a boy midshipman in the second intake of Cadet Midshipmen at the RAN College then housed in Osborne House, Geelong in 1914. Frank Getting had joined the college in the first intake the year previously. Having moved up through the ranks both Getting and Shaw were the first Australia submarine Officers to complete the “Perisher” in England. It is rather unfortunate for Shaw that as the Forces list its personnel in alphabetic order Getting gets the kudos and Shaw the footnote.

The following was written by Norman Shaw who was in his early 70s and living in Bath, England in 1972, five years after the current Squadron was commissioned at HMAS Platypus in Neutral Bay, Sydney in 1967.

RECOLLECTIONS OF COMMANDER N. H. SHAW
My first experience in submarines was with the “J” Class.

In 1919 the several Australian Ships which had been attached to the Royal Navy during the war, returned to Australia. HMAS Australia had been the flagship of the Second Battle Cruiser Squadron, HMA Ships Sydney, Melbourne, and Brisbane had been with one of the Light Cruiser Squadrons and the Destroyer Flotilla – Yarra, Parramatta, Warrego, Huon, Torrens, and Swan had been employed principally in the Mediterranean.
Additionally HMAS Platypus, which had completed building during the war and later, had served as a depot ship for RN submarines in UK waters, sailed in company with six “J” class submarines which had been “given” to the RAN.

Most of the units proceeded to Australia independently.

I was a Midshipman in HMAS Australia at the time and I recall that we took J7 in tow for a few days while on passage from Eden to Colombo. Taking passage in the Submarines were six Australian Sub Lieutenants (all of the first RANC entry), Calder, Getting, Larkins, Sadleir, Showers and Watkins.

Officers of the Flotilla were as follows:
Platypus Commander E C Boyle VC RN
J1 (Capt) LCDR R A Trevor LEUT De Mowbray (XO)
J2 ‘’ LEUT C B Barry LEUT C E Lowther ‘’
J3 ‘’ LEUT H K B Mitchell LEUT Howell-Price ‘’
J4 ‘’ LCDR A N Lee LEUT Hume-Spry ‘’
J5 ‘’ LEUT J J R Peirson LEUT C C Alexander ‘’
J7 ‘’ LCDR O E Hallifax LEUT J Drinkwater ‘’ (pictured at Blockhouse)
LEUT A. Powell was spare First Lieutenant carried in Platypus.

There were four or five RNR Lieutenants – Bunting, Dodds, Brickle, Sayle and another who were “navigators” of the submarines. They were always referred to themselves as the “Spearmints” because of their “Wrigley” stripes.

Of the Sub Lieutenants I cannot recall which boat they were in except in the case of Larkins who was washed overboard from J2 in Karimata Straits (Indonesia). The Engineers were Broomhead, Scott, Allen, McGuffie, Bradley and Ballantyne – all RN Warrant Engineers.

In September 1919 after promotion to Sub Lieutenant I was appointed to Platypus for a submarine course. Others of my year in the same course were Casey, Dash, Gould, Spurgeon and Towers. We were replacements for Calder, Getting etc, who had returned to the UK for their short courses at Greenwich, Vernon, and Excellent etc.

On completing the course in February 1920 I was appointed to J7 which was undergoing a long refit and two months later when the visit of the Prince of Wales was imminent and ships in reserve were re-commissioned with reduced crews, I was serving first in “Parramatta” and later in “Sydney” for a total of four months before returning to the S/M Flotilla.

Earlier it had been decided to establish a Submarine Base at Osborne House Geelong (the temporary site of the RANC during 1913 and 1914 pending transfer to Jervis Bay at the end of 1914).
Platypus with J1 and J4 were the first arrivals there and J2 and J5 came along later. Platypus was secured to mooring buoys off the end of the pier with the submarines berthed alongside. The submarine crews, both Officers and men, were accommodated ashore at Osborne House

I am uncertain whether J3 and J7 ever arrived at Geelong for they were still refitting in Sydney when I left Australia in August 1921 for my short courses at Greenwich etc., and when I returned to Australia in October 1922 the base at Geelong had been closed down and J3 and J7 were then at Westernport.

The “J” class were double hull boats with an armament of 4 bow torpedo tubes (18”). I cannot remember whether or not they mounted a 4” gun.

They were propelled by three sets of 12 cylinder solid injection diesel engines giving a speed of 19 knots.

Their diving qualities were not the best, it being asserted by one experienced submarine captain that if you could drive a J boat you could drive a bath. In common with the “K” class steam propelled double hull submarines the “J”s had a very flat upper deck and casing which acted rather as one large hydroplane when an angle of more than 5 degrees was reached.

As a base, Geelong was far removed from the diving ground even when the shallower waters of Port Phillip were used instead of Bass Strait, but it was very agreeable place insofar as accommodation and recreation facilities were concerned.

J7, unlike the other five Js, had had its conning tower situated well aft over the motor room between the forward and after engine rooms. I was never able to find out the reason for this arrangement. Nobody seemed to know – it meant a long journey for the captain from his bunk in the wardroom to the control room.

My actual seagoing experience in the J boats was not very great, for much of my time was spent in J7 at Cockatoo Island.

After my return to Australia in late 1922, I spent the next two years as a watch keeper in the Flagship “Melbourne” and for a short period as 1st Lieut of the Flower Class Sloop “Marguerite” which had been re-commissioned to carry the Admiral’s Office when “Melbourne” developed “condenseritis” (sic) and “Brisbane” was temporary Flagship.
By 1924 all the former RAN Officers with any submarine experience (except Getting, Casey and myself) had decided to specialise in “G”, “T”, “N” etc.

In September 1924, Getting and I, with our wives, sailed in TSS Diogenes (Aberdeen White Star) for UK to get further submarine experience and qualify in due course for command of the two “O” class submarines which had been ordered for the RAN. Casey was to follow later to provide a spare CO.

It was a grim tragedy that Casey, such a sound, placid and competent fellow should be lost in HMS M1 when she was rammed by a Swedish ship off Start Point in November 1925.

After a short period at Fort Blockhouse I joined HMS K22 (photo) as a “spare dinner” and Getting joined HMS R4 as First Lieutenant to LCDR V.R.S. Bowlby who was Senior Submarine Officer (SSO) of the 6th Submarine Flotilla at Portland. Commander G.P. Thomson, who commanded the 6th Submarine Flotilla at the time, was second Naval Member (ACNB) shortly before the outbreak of the last war (WW1).

K22 was the former K13 which had flooded while doing diving trials in the Gareloch during the first war. The majority of the crew were saved. After re-conditioning she was, for obvious reason re-numbered K22.

Shortly before I joined her she had been commanded by LCDR Trevor who had been captain of J1 in Australia. One night when leaving Portland harbour and about to pass through the southern entrance he turned to his navigator and asked “which side of the light do we pass” reply “leave it to Port sir”. The reply should have been “to Starboard” and presently K22 hit the breakwater. Trevor, who had been considered a certainty for his brass hat in the New Year’s promotions due in a couple of weeks, missed out.
A couple of days after I had joined K22, the First Submarine Flotilla consisting of the Light Cruiser “Conquest” (Captain S), the depot ship “Cyclops”, K2 (LCDR Coltart), K4 (LCDR Boyd), K12 (LCDR D’oyley-Hughes) K22 (LCDR Busbridge) and K26 CMDR Lockhart SSO), sailed with the Atlantic Fleet on its way to the Mediterranean for combined fleet exercises with the Mediterranean Fleet.

On completion of the combined fleet exercise both fleets steamed into Palma Bay, Majorca and then followed one of the finest sights I have ever seen. Just over 100 ships came to anchor on the signal from Revenge (Admiral Oliver) – out went the lower booms, down went the boats and accommodation ladders, all awnings spread – all under a clear blue sky with the sun shining brightly.

While at Palma I received an appointment to relieve LEUT J Donovan RAN as “third hand” of submarine L.52 in the Second Submarine Flotilla based on Malta. Jack Donavan returned to the UK to take passage to Australia in HMAS Moresby and I went on to Malta. Shortly afterwards my wife joined me from UK and we spent a happy 14 months on the Mediterranean Station. A few months after I had joined L.52 the first lieutenant went back to the UK for his periscope course and I stepped into his shoes.

It was a very busy flotilla and our activities covered a very wide field. In 1925 all six submarines L.25, L.54, L.56, L.69 and L.71 were kept busy for a month at the island of Siros in the Cyclades carrying out 90 degree angled torpedo firing under the direction of LCDR G E Creasy of HMS Vernon. Creasy attained the rank of Admiral of the Fleet and clocked up his 78th birthday recently (circa 1972 Ed). The exercise was designed to find out the mean advance from the firing position to the point where the torpedo settled down on its new track 90 degrees to the right or left of its firing course.

At one time each submarine was painted a different colour to determine which colour was less likely to be sighted by an aircraft on reconnaissance. White, black, blue green, Grey and striped Mackerel were the colours – Striped Mackerel was L52 – but I never heard if cast iron conclusion was reached. I imagine much would depend on the time of the day, the amount of sunlight, cloud etc.

The L.50 class of submarines were very much like the standard L class except that they had a duck tail stern. They were very good diving boats but as Automatic Inboard Venting had not yet been introduced it was not an easy job to prevent them from breaking surface when firing a salvo of six torpedoes.

In those days the Mediterranean Fleet consisted of two Battle Squadrons (Queen Elizabeth and Iron Duke classes), two cruiser squadrons, four destroyer flotillas , one submarine flotilla, two Aircraft Carriers (Glorious and Courageous) and a variety of depot ships and small craft for target towing and the like.

Sea time was plentiful and Fleet exercises frequent. During my spell there we visited practically every friendly country, Spain, Italy, Greece, Algeria and Islands under their control.

At that time Rear Admiral A.P. Addison was RA Destroyer Flotillas – he had been Commodore and later Rear Admiral Commanding the Australia Squadron in 1922-24 and I believe he had influenced the Australian Naval Board in ordering Oxley and Otway. As an ex-torpedoman he had been Capt (S) of the Submarine Flotilla during the first war.

In 1928 when he was Vice Admiral, Director of Dockyards, he came to lunch with us at Fort Blockhouse shortly before we sailed in Oxley and Otway for Australia.

In March 1926 I returned to England with my wife and shortly afterwards Frank Getting and I commenced our Periscope course at Devonport. Our teacher Capt was LCDR C.B. Barry who had commanded J2 in Australia. The Attack Teacher was situated in the Port Library and a flotilla of H-class submarines based on HMS Maidstone (the old one) at Torpoint was available for makee learn COs to practice what they had learnt on the Attack Teacher. We soon gained confidence.

In July 1926 I was appointed in command of H.27 in the Fifth Submarine Flotilla based at Blockhouse and a week later Frank Getting assumed command of H.29 in the Sixth Flotilla based on HMS Vulcan at Portland.

While in H.27 I took the opportunity of paying a visit to Chatham dockyard where ‘Oberon’ (the prototype of the O-class) was building, and again met Jack Donovan who had returned from Australia and had been designated as First Lieutenant of Oxley when Frank Getting would assume command. There again I was also to meet CMDR G D’Oyley-Hughes who had been First Lieutenant to LCDR Dunbar Naismith VC in E.11 during the Dardanelles campaign of 1915-16. D’Oyley-Hughes had come out as Flag Lieutenant to Commodore Dumaresq in HMAS Australia in 1919.

In February 1927, I went up to Barrow-in-Furness and took up my appointment as First Lieutenant to LCDR G.J.G. Tweedy in Otway. Frank Getting had gone up there a little earlier in a similar capacity to CMDR H.R. Marrack in Oxley.

Both Marrack and Tweedy were very capable submarine captains with war experience. Naturally I knew Tweedy much better than I knew Marrack and I cannot recall ever having served with a more likable and pleasant superior Officer. Later on when we were in Malta, all of us were extremely sad when Tweedy was passed over for promotion.
During the fitting out period at Barrow other Officers and key ratings came along and when all personnel, after varying periods of service in several RN Submarine Flotillas, had arrived we started “school sessions” to get everyone acquainted with the hull construction and the various systems of pumping and flooding, venting telemotor, electrical equipment, low power etc.

Vickers had provided a suitable schoolroom in the shipyard and when the yard workmen had their lunch break we took our personnel on board to show them “in situ” what they had been taught during the forenoon. Each Saturday morning the ship’s company was given a written examination covering the week’s instruction.

Most things worked surprisingly well when several trails commenced although there were some occasions when things went wrong. On one occasion I expressed concern to the Engineering Works Manager that when some fault appeared in a piece of equipment in Oxley it was replaced by robbing Otway’s accumulation of gear and materials. He pointed out that time was of the essence to complete the first boat and the defective item would be repaired in good time for installation in Otway. However he went on to say that during the first war when they had contracts for building say – twelve submarines there was scarcely anything left at the end of the contract with which to build the twelfth boat!

Oxley did her diving trials in the Gareloch. George Tweedy and I went up there by train and stayed at the Shandon Hydro for a couple of nights and went out each day to see how everything went in Oxley. Conditions in Oxley were very crowded – in addition to a full crew there were numerous shipyard workmen and also Admiralty Overseers of various grades.

In Otway we did our diving trails a few miles to seaward of Barrow, and having done a static trim in the yard basin the previous day we expected all would go well.

When the time came and we flooded main ballast, main motors at half ahead grouped up, take her down to 25 feet – there was no apparent movement on the control room depth gauges. Tweedy had a look through the periscope and immediately ordered “blow main Ballast” – a few seconds later we hit the bottom. Fortunately it was sand. An examination showed that someone – maybe a yard workman – had overnight blanked off the small pipes connecting the gauges to the sea. Eventually our diving trails were completed without further incidents of that kind.

Throughout our time at Barrow we had Engineer CMDR C.W. Bridge RAN assisted by LEUT (E) F.C. Hodgson RAN as general Overseer – but the main overseeing responsibility was that of the Admiralty through who the Australian Government had placed the order.

The Managing Director of the Vickers Yard at Barrow was Commander Charles Craven (a few years later Sir Charles) who had been a submariner himself and anything within reason that we asked for was readily provided by him.

On frequent occasions he invited all the officers and their wives to Sunday supper at his official residence – Abbey House – very jolly evenings they were indeed.

After completion at Barrow, Oxley went on to Chatham Dockyard for the installation of Asdic equipment and we in Otway followed later. While at Chatham we were all accommodated in the RN Barracks.

One rather tiresome job we had there was breaking down of the Specific Gravity of the electrolyte in our batteries. This involved drawing off the electrolyte covering the top of the plates and replacing them it with distilled water – the operation having to be repeated three times, immediately after re-charging, before the target specified gravity was reached.

From Chatham we went on to Blockhouse for a short period before going on to Portland for exercise with the Anti Submarine Flotilla based there. Oxley went on later for deep diving trials off the Scilly Isles – she was to go down to 300 feet but on the way there received instructions by signal to limit the depth to 200 feet. She had been designed for a depth of 500 feet.

While Otway was at Portland we developed a serious steering defect – after clearing the breakwater one morning she would not answer her helm and started turning circles. Examination showed that the rudder crosshead had fractured, and as the rudder was “overbalanced” it would only remain in hard over position while making way through the water.
We were taken back to harbour by tugs and after the rudder had been clamped to the tail fin in an amidships position we left for Portsmouth, steering with our engines and with a tug as escort. Eventually a team from Vickers arrived to fit a new and modified crosshead.

Oxley and Otway sailed in company for Australia from Portsmouth in April 1928.

Oxley
CMDR H.R Marrack DSC RN
LEUT F.E. Getting RAN
LEUT J. Donovan RAN
LEUT J.B.S. Barwood RAN
LEUT A.E. Fowler RAN
LEUT (E) F.C. Hodgson RAN
Wt ENG J.A. Hutton RAN

Otway
LCDR G.J.D Tweedy RN
LEUT N.H. Shaw RAN
LEUT J.A.A. Stocks RAN
LEUT L.R. Brooks RAN
SLEUT H.C. Wright RAN
SLEUT M.L. Power RN
Wt ENG A Nairn RAN

(Sub Lieutenant Power ended his naval service a few years ago (late 1960s Ed) as Admiral Sir Manley Lawrence Power KCB C-in-C Portsmouth).

After a brief visit to Gibraltar we continued on our way to Malta and during that passage the Engineer Officer of Otway (Alex Nairn) reported evidence of cracks in the columns of the main engines. On arrival at Malta an examination of Oxley’s engine columns revealed cracks also.

Engineering experts, both naval and from Vickers, pondered over the problem for some time and eventually it was decided that the engines should be rebuilt with new modified columns.

A minesweeper in reserve, HMS Stoke, was made available as an accommodation ship during the long period over which the necessary work was undertaken by HM Dockyard Malta under the supervision of personnel from Vickers. Some Officers and ratings returned to UK for further training and some returned to Australia.

Towards the end of the period, Engineer Captain J.J.C Brand RAN and the Engineering works Manager from Vickers (Mr. W. Johnson) paid a visit on behalf of their separate interests and before they left they jointly gave a dinner party to the Officers and wives heading the invitation “If this be the price of Admiralty, my God we have both paid in full”

As both CMDR Marrack and LCDR Tweedy would have completed their two year period of service with the RAN before the submarines could possibly arrive in Australia, they asked to be relieved.

CMDR A. Gordon Hine DSO was appointed to Otway as Senior Officer Submarines and Frank Getting, who had put up his half stripe while we were in Malta, was appointed in command of Oxley.

Otway and Oxley sailed from Malta towards the end of November 1928 and after a short call at Port Said for fresh provisions continued on through the Suez Canal. When half way down the Red Sea we were overtaken by our wives who had returned from Australia to be with us in Malta, travelling in SS Orama. They were crashing on at eighteen knots while we lumbered along at an average of about twelve knots.

After three days at Aden we set off for Colombo making a fair passage with only minor engine stoppages. There we were topped up with fresh provisions from Colombo Cold Storage Co. which included Australian sirloin of beef. (After arrival in Sydney we were admonished by the ACNB through the agency of Director of Victualling for having brought sirloin at 10p per pound instead of rolled ribs at 8p per lb!!!) We were in Colombo for about a week during which CMDR Hine went up country with his wife who was passing through on her way to Australia.

We arrived in Balawan Deli two days before Christmas and were made welcome by the British residents of Medan. On Christmas Eve both submarines were deserted with only one Officer and a few key ratings left on board. The remainder of us were accorded hospitality over Christmas by the British community. CMDR Hine and I stayed with the Consul in great comfort and were taken up to the hill station at Brastagi for Christmas dinner.

Our next stop was Singapore where we spent New Year’s day CMDR R.D. King-Harman (a Singapore Pilot) who had been the navigator of HMAS Sydney a few years previously, organised all kinds of entertainment and recreation for both Officers and men during our visit.

On to Batavia where we needed help in the way of re-winding of the armatures of our water and oil pumps. This was undertaken by Radio Holland at Tanjong Priok and they made an excellent job. The British residents of Batavia extended much hospitality to both Officers and men. While there we were joined by HMS Kent, flagship of Admiral Tyrwhitt and met an old shipmate or two. One was LCDR P.L.Vian of Cossack fame in later years. He had been LEUT (G) of HMAS Australia when I was a midshipman. I had recently put up my half stripe and he remarked that I had caught up with him. As he subsequently became an Admiral of the Fleet I had to concede the race to him!

From Batavia we went on to Koepang in Timor and after a couple of days, on again to Thursday Island where Platypus awaited our arrival. Preparations for Platypus to resume her erstwhile role of Submarine Depot Ship had been sadly lacking – no mess decks were available for our ship’s companies.

On the way south we called in at Townsville and Brisbane before arriving in Sydney in February 1929. Shortly afterwards CMDR Hine took command of Platypus and I took command of Otway.

Then followed a period of Foreign Service leave for all.

LEUT Barwood of Oxley had come to Otway as my First Lieutenant and LCDR G.A.W Voelcker RN who had taken passage out in Canberra went to Platypus in the in the dual capacity of First Lieutenant and Spare S/m Captain.

Later in the year Platypus, Oxley and Otway sailed for Jervis Bay from where we worked up to a reasonable state of efficiency after such a long period of diving inactivity.

Occasionally, as opportunity offered, we were able to carry out attacks on Australia and Canberra but torpedo firing was not frequent owing to a lack of vessels available for picking up torpedoes with nicely crushed heads after attacks on the cruisers. When attacking other ships the torpedoes were set to “run under”. When exercising independently inside Jervis Bay, I frequently fired torpedoes for the sake of keeping the TGM and his team up to scratch in their preparation tests. In calm waters we could recover our own torpedoes.

Some time after we returned to Sydney, Jack Donovan and Ben Barwood left for UK for periscope course – Fowler then became First Lieutenant of Oxley and Brooks in Otway.

The next occasion we used Jervis Bay was after Platypus had become HMAS Penguin and moored securely alongside Garden Island, and after both submarines had undergone an extensive refit. CMDR Hine took passage with me in Otway and conducted operations from ashore at the Collage. Oxley followed shortly afterwards. HMAS Anzac (LCDR Paul Hirst) came along to act as target and recovery vessel.

Shortly after we had returned to Sydney we received information that the submarines were to pay off into immediate reserve. (The world financial depression had started).

Frank Getting went to UK for his “big ship” time; CMDR Hine and LCDR Voelcker left for the UK and I remained as Senior Officer Submarines in reserve with reduced crews.

From the foregoing it will be appreciated that we never really got going.

In reserve I had some difficulty in obtaining permission to take alternate submarines to sea each week for a day’s diving. Money was short and fuel expensive. Never again did we fire a torpedo, but occasionally I could fluke a target vessel on passage to some place.

Later when it was decided that Oxley and Otway were to be transferred to the Royal Navy the takeover went smoothly with both submarines in sound working order. CMDR E.M. Loly took over Oxley and LCDR T.H. Dickson took Otway.

It is my opinion that (a) it would have been wiser for Australia to have waited until the “O” class had been proved before ordering Oxley and Otway, for they were in fact the guinea pigs of the class, and (b) had it not been the financial depression we would have had a fair prospect of establishing successfully, on the third attempt an Australian Submarine Flotilla.

Shortly after the submarines had been taken over by the Royal Navy I came to UK in August 1931 and before joining HMS Ramillies at Malta, I called on Rear Admiral Submarines (Naismith) at Blockhouse. He questioned me on several matters and asked why we had not fitted Davis Escape Apparatus while the submarines were in reserve. I told him that the Naval Board had sought my opinion and I had advised against. He asked “Why”. My reply was that (a) I took the view that it was much better to prevent a submarine being sunk than to seek ways of rescuing the crew after it had been sunk. “And how do you propose to do that?” He asked. And (b). My answer was “By being more careful and discriminating in the selection of your Submarine Captains.

I cannot recall any submarine disaster in peacetime which was not attributable to negligence, and in most cases the Captain himself was either negligent or incompetent. In other cases the negligence derived from lack of supervision and/or lack of training, both of which could usually be traced back to indolence on the part of the Captain.

While in UK at that time I met up with LCDR Leathes who had been my captain in L.25 some years before. He was now in Command of M.2, one of the M-class which had originally mounted a 12” gun. M.2’s gun turret had been replaced by a hanger housing a small seaplane which had been catapulted along rails set up on the forward casing. Leathes invited me onboard for a short demonstration in the vicinity of the Isle of Wright. Quite an interesting performance – we dived, and on surfacing the hangar was opened and after a very short interval the seaplane was catapulted off, did a few circles and low passes before landing on the surface alongside, was hoisted in, stowed away and we dived again .

That was the last time I ever dived in a submarine – over forty years ago (circa 1932 Ed).

Some months later M.2 was lost with all hands. I believe the hangar door was opened too soon when surfacing.

Apart from submarine X.1 which was a purely experimental venture the “O” class were first of the post war (WW1) new construction programme. They were probably best described as a modified saddle tank submarines in so far as the hull was concerned. If I remember correctly their surface displacement was in the region of 1400 tons. The pressure hull was 1 inch plating calculated to permit a maximum diving depth of 500 feet.

The only external ballast tanks with Kingstons were Nos. 4, 7 and 8 which could be, and were, used as reserve fuel tanks. Additionally Nos 3 and 9 external ballast tanks had smaller fuel tanks built within them. Although these arrangements for fuel stowage gave the vessels great range of endurance, there was a crucial disadvantage in the matter of oil leaks from these lightly constructed tanks. The differential two-way relief valve installation – spring loaded to 6 lbs – was not satisfactory and my experience was that it was well nigh impossible to avoid leaving a tell-tale oil slick when diving. I expect a solution was found before the outbreak of war (WW2), otherwise many more of our submarines would have been lost.
Many new features in these submarines were incorporated for the first time.

All vent, Kingstons and blowing controls for the external and internal ballast tanks were operated from central telemotor panel in the Control Room.

The LP Blowers were of a new rotary type replacing the former reciprocating blowers.
Centrifugal ballast pumps replaced the old reciprocating type.

The Main Engines were blast injection diesels giving a speed of about 15 knots. The pistons were of aluminium and were oiled cooled through an arrangement of walking pipes connected to a circulating pump – the cooling agent was sea water.

The main batteries were housed in battery rooms, 3 in number, instead of battery tanks as hitherto. Each cell of the Exide Ironclad batteries had a connection to the battery ventilating system on the exhaust side, and on the supply side the air passed through a cooler serviced by the CO2 refrigeration plant.

The batteries could be “grouped up” to supply 330 volts to the main motors by splitting No.3 battery and connecting half in series with each of Nos 1 and 2 batteries. All auxiliary motors and power remained on 220 volts when “grouped up” and the Reducer was then switched to “levelling” to preserve an equal discharge from each of the three batteries.

The Main Motors were totally enclosed and ventilated by fans drawing air through sea water coolers.

The refrigeration plant enabled the storage of a limited quantity of fresh meat and could also produce six blocks of ice per day.

The fresh water supply could be augmented by passing the exhaust gases of the Main Engines through an evaporator.
The Forward and After hydroplanes and steering gear were powered by Williams-Janney Variable Speed gear with telemotor control from the Control Room.

The armament consisted of six bow and two stern 21 inch torpedo tubes. Bow caps were telemotor powered and the tubes had Automatic Inboard Venting, Electro-Magnetic firing gear and access openings for 90 degree angling and alteration of depth setting.

The periscopes were 30 feet but otherwise were much the same as the shorter periscopes in earlier use.

Water cooled Valve transmission was an innovation in the W/T equipment.

On the domestic side a cook rating and an Officers steward were included in the complement for the first time. In Harbour the cook used an oil fired galley in the forward casing.

A skiff powered by a small engine carrying its own petrol tank was stowed in the after casing – very useful too after the old Berthon Boats.

Oxley and Otway were very good diving craft and most manageable. For their time, they were comfortable to live in.
It was much to be regretted that the circumstances prevented Frank Getting and the rest of us from establishing a good foundation for an Australian Submarine Service.

I hope that this latest effort to maintain a squadron (that is the modern term I understand) of Submarines in Australia will be successful.


THE U-BOATS WERE BEDAZZLED by Rupert Butler.
Dazzle was a revolutionary naval deception technique designed to confuse WW1 German U-boats on speed and course of Allied ships. Accounts of how Dazzle worked are revealed in ‘Camouflage” an exhibition running until 18 November 2007 at the Imperial War Museum in London.

The introduction of Dazzle came at a crucial point of the war, spurred by a dramatic announcement in February 1917 from the Imperial German Chancellor Theobald von Bethmann-Hollweg that the country was increasing its aggressive policy of unrestricted submarine warfare.

It involved all ships travelling within a war zone, even those from neutral countries, if they were suspected of transporting aid to England.

Between March and December, U-boats sank 925 ships. In mid-April came the blackest period, with 55 destroyed in a single week for an average of almost eight ships per day, Says James Taylor IWM historian and exhibit curator: “What evolved on the Allied side amounted to a revolution in camouflage. This was visual mimicry, which had already been foreshadowed by Q-Ships. These were armed British vessels disguised as unarmed merchant ships, often flying flags of neutral countries. Their role was to attack a U-boat when they closed with what the German Commander believed to be unarmed ships. By then the Q-Ships had unveiled their guns and were firing at close range. For a while this ruse worked but it was not nearly enough.”

Conventional camouflage was strictly limited – a truth increasingly recognised by a group of illustrators, marine painters and designers, predominately 39-year old Royal Navy Lieutenant Norman Wilkinson. He later explained: “Since it was impossible to paint a ship so that she could not be seen by a submarine, the extreme opposite was the answer…To paint her, not for low visibility, but in such a way as to break up form and thus confuse a submarine officer as to the course on which she was heading.”

Therefore, the purpose was not concealment but to make the enemy think it was seeing a different size, type or class of vessel making identification hard.

An approach was made by Wilkinson to the Admiralty which at first merely sat on the idea. But, faced with continual heavy losses, it had a change of heart Within a short time, a group of artists were making up the Dazzle Section, using studios at London’s Royal Academy (Art Gallery/Institute Ed). A number of them had taken their inspiration for their new work from nature, discovering, for example that zebras had the knack of displaying camouflage makings pointing in one direction when in fact an entire heard was intent on another. A small store ship, HMS Industry, was painted in experimental Dazzle. Shore stations and vessels were ordered to report their impressions on sighting her and comment on the likely effectiveness. Success exceeded all expectations. An order went out that 50 troopships were to be Dazzle-painted. Work began with wooden models of vessels already chosen for Dazzle. Surprise was a major factor, with the designs made as varied as possible and always different on each side of the ship.

Then the models were studied through periscopes with the results forwarded to the ports where vessels waited for Dazzle to be applied Results were judged to be so effective that by October 1917 the Admiralty directed that Dazzle should be painted on all armed and unarmed merchant ships, particularly those carrying vital munitions.

Within eight months, more than 2,300 were ‘Dazzled’. Transport vessels on the Atlantic run, many leaving from Portsmouth, were among the first. Ships frequently underwent more than one Dazzle painting, typified by the British troopship Olympic, which by war’s end had transported 41,000 civilian passengers and 66,000 troops surviving a torpedo attack in the English channel from a U-boat she had rammed. So as to confuse other U-boats, strips previously across Olympic’s bows were removed and four oval shapes painted on her port side between the first and second funnels. Dazzle also extended round the funnels, masts and ventilators and even over the lifeboats.

Early in 1918, Norman Wilkinson visited the United States to advise the Navy Department on design and deceptive colouring for both merchant vessels and warships.

Eventually, thanks to backing from the US Navy’s Assistant Secretary Franklin D. Roosevelt, all pre-Dazzle systems for Dazzle. During the final eight months final eight months of war, more than 1,200 American ships sported Dazzle schemes, about half of which were modifications of British designs.

Cunard had long pledged Britain that it would place its fleet at its disposal in time of war. The company’s Mauritania, sporting a distinctive confusing patchwork Dazzle scheme, was initially intended for use as an armed cruiser, but was converted in 1915 to a troopship. She then became a hospital ship, reverting finally to troopship status, bringing 33,000 American soldiers to Europe in the spring of 1918.

With the close of WW1, Dazzle painting fell into disfavour. Rigidly traditional elements in the US and Britain had never liked what they regarded as the intrusion of painters, regarded as tiresome amateurs. One senior American serviceman had even fulminated “O, God, as if we didn’t have enough trouble! They send us artists.” Although America reintroduced Dazzle in WW2 to a limited extent in the face of a new submarine threat, it was clear that improvements in radar and sonar were removing any need for submarine commanders to sight their targets visually. The blunt truth was that Dazzle had outlived its use. For warships in WW2 it was back to conventional grey, along with some simpler disruptive patterns used. The Imperial War Museum’s James Taylor points out: “At one point, the Admiralty had carried out a study discovering that one of the effects of Dazzle had been as a marvellous moral booster for merchant crews. They were able to see not only their own vessels but others in harbour in a range of colours. It gave them a sense of reassurance. It was possibly Dazzle’s most positive achievement.

For more details on the Imperial War Museum and its camouflage exhibition visit the web site www.iwm.org.uk


AXIS SUBMARINES OF WORLD WAR II
The struggle for supremacy above and beneath the swirling waters of the North Atlantic was the most important battle fought by submarine forces of the Axis navies, but was far from being the sole scene of operations. Indeed, Axis submarines ranged the sea lanes from the Atlantic through the Indian Ocean to the South Pacific.

During World War Two the common factor that permitted the USA to wage war in both Europe and Pacific simultaneously, and which allowed the UK to exist at all, was merchant shipping. Losses of warships could cause problems, but losses of merchantmen were potentially disastrous. If the loss rate has exceeded the construction rate for a significant period, the Allies’ capacity to wage war would have slowed, to the point eventually of capitulation.

As World War One had adequately proved to the Germans that submarines were the best vehicles for this form of warfare, it seems extraordinary that more resources were not put into their construction in the late 1930s. Those available caused damage enough, but greater numbers and a higher construction rate from the outset would have swamped the ability of current Allied defences to cope.

Throughout the conflict, the Germans stove to improve both the technical quality of their boats and the methods by which they could best be employed, natural energy that contrasted strangely with that of their Axis partners. Both Italy and Japan had sizable submarine fleets and, as each joined the war at later dates, they had adequate time to learn at first hand the problems of submarine warfare before actually committing themselves.
Italy, however, found her boats to be deficient in quality and their crews both poorly trained and, in many cases, suffering form the same lack of motivation and conviction that affected her surface fleet.

Japan, on the other hand, had no lack of motivation but was stricken with an inflexibility of purpose that worked to the American advantage. War waged against merchant shipping was viewed as ‘defensive’ so, despite in most cases being manifestly unsuitable for the purpose, Japanese submarines were employed almost exclusively against warships. The twin fact that American lines of communication vulnerably straddled two oceans and that American submarines were throttling Japan by blockade appeared unnoticed.

There was no lack of sacrifice. In pursuing their various objectives, the Axis partners lost over 950 boats in action and many more from other causes.

The above story is from the magazine “War Machine” volume 6 issue 62, published by Orbis Publishing Ltd.
 

NEW MEMBERS – WELCOME ABOARD

Collins, A.E. (Tony) Tewantin QLD 4565 - CPOERASM HMS/ms Token, Cachalot and HMAS Oxley 1963 – 1968

Millar, R. J. (Bob) - Vista, CA USA 92084 4615 - ETCS(SS) USS Thresher SSN-593, Patrick Henry SSBN-599, James Monroe SSBN-622
and Sam Houston SSBN-609 1960 – 1978

Pegler, J.R. (Pegs) Thuringowa, Qld 4817 - LSTDSM HMAS Otama and Otway 1988 – 1993

Robinson, J. (Robbo) Ardross, WA 6153 - WOETSM HMAS Orion twice, Otama twice, Waller and Sheean 1988 – 2003

Russell, P.J. Goodanup, WA 6210 - CPOMTPSM HMAS Ovens twice, Otway thrice, and Otama 1978 – 1992

EDITOR’S COMMENTS

It is with regret that I announce the passing of Dorothy Selby, the wife of Gordon. On his crossing the bar, Dorothy went to a nursing home, without her coxswain to guide her Dorothy passed quietly away several weeks ago..

You may have noticed that there are many reports not printed and I know that the Max’s report was emailed to me twice and I still have not received it. I am not an RO, so I have no idea where these messages go before they are delivered to me by my server.

On behalf of the National President David Sandquest, Vice President Max Hardy, Treasurer John Rana I wish all readers of In Depth a Very Merry Christmas.

Peter Smith.
Hon Nat Secretary
November 2007


SUBCON 2008

To be held in Canberra on the Queen's Birthday long weekend, commencing

Friday 6th June 2008 

The Branch would like to invite you to the Australian Capital Territory and surrounding area to partake of our hospitality and to visit the many interesting and varied places contained within our region.

Visit the SUBCON 2008 website for details and complete your Registration of Interest. 

 


  Proud to support "In Depth" and the Submarines Association Australia

Proud Sponsors of submarinesaustralia.com

Send mail to norm.williams@submarinesaustralia.com with questions or comments about this web site.
Copyright © 2007 Submarines Association Australia
Last modified: 13-Feb-2008 03:47:40 PM